Skip to content
Karanfiloglu Law Firm

Civil Law

How to File a False Accusation (İftira) Case? TCK 267, Process and Compensation

Author:

· · 19 min read

A false accusation case (iftira davası) technically begins with a criminal complaint (suç duyurusu) to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office (Cumhuriyet Başsavcılığı): false accusation is an offence under Article 267 of the Turkish Penal Code (Türk Ceza Kanunu, TCK) that does not depend on a complaint by the victim and that the prosecutor investigates of their own motion. In practice, the application is made after the baseless accusation has ended with a decision in your favour. Separately, you can claim material and moral damages (maddi ve manevi tazminat) for the harm you suffered before a civil court.

Someone made up a complaint about you, you gave a statement, perhaps you went through an investigation or a trial that lasted months, and in the end you received a non-prosecution decision or an acquittal. The question on your mind now is clear: will the person who did this knowingly face any consequences? Below we explain the elements of the offence of false accusation, how it differs from insult and from fabricating an offence, when and where to apply, the evidence, the compensation route and the most common mistakes.

A false accusation case is not a single case: the criminal route and the compensation route

What is called a "false accusation case" in everyday language covers two separate legal routes.

  • Criminal route: A criminal complaint is filed with the prosecutor's office so that the person who made the false accusation is punished. The prosecutor conducts the investigation; if there is sufficient suspicion, an indictment (iddianame) is drawn up and the trial takes place in a criminal court.
  • Civil route: A compensation claim is filed in the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) to make good the harm you suffered because of the false accusation (lawyer's fees and costs, loss of earnings, damage to your reputation, psychological distress).

The two routes are independent of each other, but they affect each other. Statements taken in the criminal file, and especially a conviction, give strong support in the compensation case. That is why, in most files, the criminal complaint is made first and the compensation case is timed according to how the criminal file develops.

Because false accusation is not an offence that depends on a complaint, the prosecutor must act of their own motion as soon as they learn of the offence. Saying later "I withdraw my complaint" does not close the file. As a rule, false accusation is also not among the offences eligible for victim-offender reconciliation (uzlaşma); even if the parties reach an agreement between themselves, the investigation continues.

Elements of the offence of false accusation (TCK Art. 267)

In summary, the law defines false accusation as follows: attributing an unlawful act to a person, while knowing that they did not commit it, by reporting or complaining to the competent authorities or through the press and media, and doing so in order to have an investigation or prosecution opened against that person or an administrative sanction imposed on them. The penalty for the basic form of the offence is imprisonment from one to four years.

For an incident to count as false accusation, the following elements must all be present:

  • A specific person: The accusation must be aimed at someone whose identity is known or can be determined. Reporting an offence that one knows was not committed as if it had been committed, without pointing at anyone, is fabricating an offence, which is explained below.
  • Attribution of an unlawful act: The act attributed may be an offence, or it may be conduct that calls for an administrative sanction (for example, an act that would lead to a disciplinary penalty or an administrative fine).
  • Notification to a competent authority, or the press and media: An application to an authority with power to act, such as the prosecutor's office, law enforcement, a public body or a disciplinary superior; or an accusation made through media such as newspapers, television or online news sites.
  • Knowingly lying: The perpetrator must know that the other person did not commit the act. A complaint made by mistake, on incomplete information or in good faith is not false accusation.
  • Purpose: To bring about an investigation, a prosecution or an administrative sanction against the victim.

The element most often disputed is the "knowingly" requirement. The fact that the complaint against you came to nothing does not, on its own, show that the other side made a false accusation. For example, where a non-prosecution decision was given for lack of sufficient evidence, the prosecutor will separately consider the possibility that the complainant genuinely believed the incident happened. Making a complaint is part of the freedom to seek legal remedies (hak arama özgürlüğü) protected by the Constitution. False accusation only comes into play when this right is knowingly abused.

The law also provides for aggravated forms. The penalty increases in situations such as where the act is committed by fabricating physical traces and evidence, where a protective measure such as police custody (gözaltı) or pre-trial detention (tutuklama) is applied to the victim because of the false accusation, and where the victim is wrongly convicted. In files with serious consequences, the penalty range is much higher than for the basic form, and the court that hears the case may also change.

Differences between false accusation, insult and fabricating an offence

These three offences are often confused. Classifying the act wrongly can make you miss the time limit for applying, especially in the case of insult (hakaret).

PointFalse accusation (TCK Art. 267)Insult (TCK Art. 125)Fabricating an offence (TCK Art. 271)
Is a specific person targeted?YesYesNo, the perpetrator does not point at anyone
Essence of the actKnowingly attributing a false offence or administrative violation, to a competent authority or through the pressAttributing a concrete act or fact that offends a person's honour, dignity and reputation, or swearing at themReporting an offence that was not committed as if it had been, or fabricating evidence of an offence
Who pursues it?The prosecutor, of their own motion (re'sen)As a rule, upon the victim's complaintThe prosecutor, of their own motion
Time limit for applyingNo complaint period; the limitation period for prosecution runsAs a rule, 6 months from learning of the act and the perpetrator; in any event 2 years from the actNo complaint period; the limitation period for prosecution runs

Let us give a concrete example. If your neighbour writes in a messaging group of your residential complex that reaches at least three people that you are a thief, this is, as a rule, insult. If the same person goes to the police station and files a theft complaint against you while knowing that you stole nothing, this may amount to false accusation. If they did both, the two offences come into play together, and the six-month period runs separately for the insult. For complaints about insult, see our articles on complaints for threats and insults and insults on social media.

When should a criminal complaint for false accusation be made?

The law contains no requirement that "you must first have been acquitted". However, when assessing a false accusation claim, prosecutors look at the outcome of the first file, because the fact that you did not commit the act attributed to you usually emerges in that file. For this reason, in practice the application is usually made after one of the following decisions has become final:

  • A non-prosecution decision (kovuşturmaya yer olmadığına dair karar) given in the investigation against you (after the time limit for objection has passed or the objection has been rejected),
  • An acquittal (beraat) given at the end of the trial (once it has become final, either without any appeal being lodged or after the appeals have been exhausted),
  • If the accusation was aimed at an administrative sanction, for example in a disciplinary investigation, the decision that no penalty is to be imposed or that shows the accusation was unfounded.

Applying early is not prohibited. You can make a criminal complaint while the first file is still ongoing; in that case, however, the prosecutor will often wait for the outcome of the first file, or may decide not to prosecute on the ground that there is insufficient evidence. In practice, the soundest course is to gather the evidence while the first file is ongoing and to make the criminal complaint once the decision becomes final, together with a copy bearing the finality annotation (kesinleşme şerhi).

Limitation period

Because false accusation does not depend on a complaint, the six-month complaint period that applies to insult does not apply here. Instead, the limitation periods for prosecution (dava zamanaşımı) in TCK Art. 66 apply. These periods depend on the upper limit of the penalty the law sets for the offence; for the basic form of false accusation an eight-year period applies as a rule, and for aggravated forms the period may be longer. The law also lays down a special starting rule for false accusation: the limitation period for prosecution begins to run from the date on which the victim's innocence is established, which in practice is usually the date on which the decision in their favour became final. Even so, waiting weakens the file. Years later, witnesses no longer remember the incident, and camera and traffic recordings have been deleted.

How to file a false accusation case: step by step

  1. Obtain the whole of the first file. From the investigation or prosecution file against you, obtain the complaint petition, the records of the complainant's statements and the decision bearing the finality annotation. Your lawyer can access these documents through UYAP, the judiciary's online system.
  2. Set aside the evidence showing that the accusation was knowingly false. Messages showing that the complainant knew you were somewhere else at the time of the incident, or statements that contradict each other, are the core of this stage.
  3. Prepare the criminal complaint petition. The petition should state the identity of the suspect, the date on which and the authority to which the false accusation was made, the act attributed, the case and decision numbers (esas ve karar numarası) of the first file, the date on which the decision became final and a list of evidence. The request is that a public prosecution be brought against the suspect under TCK Art. 267.
  4. Make the application. The criminal complaint can be filed directly with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office or with law enforcement units (the police or the gendarmerie). The chief prosecutor's office in the place where the false accusation was made is usually preferred; a petition filed elsewhere is forwarded to the competent prosecutor's office. No court fee (harç) is payable for a criminal complaint.
  5. Follow the investigation. The prosecutor may hear you as the victim, summons the suspect to give a statement and obtains the first file. This is the most suitable stage for submitting additional evidence.
  6. Use the remedies against decisions. If the prosecutor decides not to prosecute, you can, as a rule, object to the criminal judgeship of peace (sulh ceza hâkimliği) within 15 days of notification. If an indictment is drawn up, you can join the trial as an intervening party (katılan, also called müdahil), submit evidence and appeal against the judgment.

If a file opened against you as a result of a false accusation is still ongoing, your priority is your defence; our article on criminal defence may guide you on this.

How long does the process take?

It is not possible to give a definite duration; the prosecutor's workload, the nature of the evidence and the time it takes to obtain the first file are decisive. The investigation stage usually lasts between a few months and a year. If the indictment is accepted, the basic form is, as a rule, heard by the criminal court of first instance (asliye ceza mahkemesi), and with several hearings the trial may last more than a year. An appeal before the regional court of appeal (istinaf) may be added to this and, depending on the length of the sentence, a further appeal to the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), known as temyiz.

Evidence in a false accusation case

In a false accusation file, two things must be proved: that the accusation was untrue, and that the complainant knew this. The first usually emerges from the decision in the first file. The second requires separate evidence. The main evidence that can be used is:

  • The complaint petition in the first file and the complainant's statements; contradictions between the stages are among the strongest evidence.
  • The non-prosecution decision or acquittal bearing the finality annotation, and its reasoning.
  • Correspondence with the complainant (WhatsApp, email, SMS); messages such as "I'll report you and get you fired" in particular can show intent.
  • Records showing that you were elsewhere at the time of the incident: motorway toll (HGS) passes, camera footage, workplace entry records, boarding passes, bank card spending.
  • Witnesses who were present when the complainant voiced their intention.
  • For a false accusation made through the press and media, the publication itself: the link to the news item, the publication date and, if possible, a notarial record (noter tespiti).

With digital evidence, a screenshot on its own is often not enough. Preserve the phone containing the messages, the sender's number and the date information; make a backup before changing the device. Evidence obtained unlawfully, for example messages taken by accessing someone else's phone without permission, may not only be unusable but may also create separate liability for you. The evidential value of a secret audio recording, for its part, is quite limited and disputed. We recommend that you seek advice before taking such a step.

Effective repentance (TCK Art. 269)

The law provides for a reduction in the penalty if the person who made the false accusation retracts it. The rate of reduction varies with the stage at which repentance (etkin pişmanlık) is shown. A person who retracts before an investigation is opened against the victim benefits from the largest reduction; where the retraction comes after the prosecution has begun or after the victim has been convicted, the reduction is smaller. For a false accusation made through the press and media, the retraction must, as a rule, also be published in the same way.

This rule has a practical meaning for the victim. If the complainant withdraws their statement while the first file is ongoing and declares that the accusation was untrue, this statement may help your file to be closed. The reduction, however, does not mean that no false accusation was committed. A criminal complaint can still be made, and the court sets the penalty with the reduction applied.

Material and moral damages for false accusation

False accusation is also a tort (haksız fiil). Under Art. 49 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (Türk Borçlar Kanunu, TBK), a person who harms another through a culpable and unlawful act must make good that harm. TBK Art. 58 provides that a person whose personality rights have been violated may claim moral damages.

  • Material damages: The lawyer's fees and costs you paid in the first file, earnings lost because of police custody or pre-trial detention, dismissal or loss of work, and medical expenses. Each item must be documented.
  • Moral damages: Loss of reputation, psychological distress and the strain suffered in your family and work circles. The judge sets the amount at their discretion, using criteria such as the seriousness of the accusation, how widely it spread, the measures applied and the circumstances of the parties.

The compensation case is filed in the civil court of first instance. You do not have to wait for the outcome of the criminal file; however, the civil judge may stay the case pending the criminal file or make use of the evidence in it. As a rule, an acquittal by the criminal court does not bind the civil judge, but the findings in a conviction on the existence of the act give strong support. The limitation period is governed by TBK Art. 72: as a rule, two years from learning of the harm and the person liable, and in any event ten years from the act; if the act is an offence for which the criminal laws provide a longer limitation period, that period applies. The court fees paid when filing the case are updated every year; you should check the current amounts on the date of filing. For more on the heads of compensation, see our articles on material and moral damages and compensation claims in insult cases.

Common mistakes in false accusation cases

  • Treating every unsuccessful complaint as false accusation. Read the reasoning of the decision. "Insufficient evidence" and "the act never took place" are different things, and the difference directly affects the strength of a false accusation file.
  • Confusing insult with false accusation and missing the time limit. If the same person also accused you on social media, the six-month complaint period for insult runs for those posts without waiting for the false accusation file.
  • Not documenting finality. Applications made with a decision that has no finality annotation are often put on hold. Confirm with the court or the prosecutor's office that the decision has become final.
  • Not preserving evidence. Changing your phone, deleting messages or not requesting camera recordings in time makes it harder to prove intent.
  • Writing to the other side in anger. Messages such as "I'll get you locked up" may lead to a new file being opened against you. Communicate through your lawyer.

In short, a false accusation case begins with a criminal complaint and draws its strength from two things: a final decision in your favour and evidence showing that the other side knew they were lying. The criminal route and the compensation route should be planned separately, and the time limits calculated from the very start. Do not rush, but do not mistake waiting for a strategy either.

Speak with a Lawyer in Istanbul

If you would like legal advice on your own situation, Karanfiloglu Law Firm is a registered law firm in Istanbul serving foreign and Turkish clients across Turkey. You can reach us by phone or WhatsApp on +90 532 659 35 11, by email at karanfiloglu.lawyer@gmail.com, or visit our office at Merkez Mah. Hasat Sk. No:12, 34384 Şişli / İstanbul. You can read about our work on false accusation and other criminal files on our criminal law page, and contact us to discuss your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an acquittal required to file a false accusation case?

The law has no such requirement. However, because the untruth of the accusation usually emerges from the outcome of the first file, in practice the criminal complaint is usually made after the non-prosecution decision or the acquittal has become final. With early applications, the prosecutor most often waits for the outcome of the first file.

Where is a criminal complaint for false accusation filed?

The criminal complaint can be filed with the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office or with law enforcement units such as the police or the gendarmerie. The chief prosecutor's office in the place where the false accusation was made is usually preferred. The application is made by petition and no court fee is payable; a lawyer can also send it through UYAP.

Can a false accusation complaint be withdrawn?

Because false accusation is not an offence that depends on a complaint, the prosecutor conducts the investigation of their own motion. As a rule, the victim's withdrawal or an agreement between the parties does not close the file. Withdrawing the complaint affects, at most, your decision on whether to file a compensation case.

What is the penalty for false accusation?

Under TCK Art. 267, the penalty for the basic form is imprisonment from one to four years. The penalty increases in situations such as where evidence is fabricated, where a measure such as police custody or pre-trial detention is applied to the victim, or where the victim is wrongly convicted. If the perpetrator retracts the false accusation, the effective repentance reduction in TCK Art. 269 may come into play.

What is the difference between false accusation and insult?

Insult targets a person's honour and dignity and, as a rule, depends on a complaint; the complaint period is six months from learning of the act and the perpetrator, and in any event it cannot exceed two years from the date the act was committed. False accusation, by contrast, means knowingly attributing a false offence or administrative violation to someone, to the competent authorities or through the press, with the aim of having an investigation opened against the victim, and the prosecutor pursues it of their own motion.

Is accusing someone of an offence on social media false accusation?

It can be. The law also covers accusations made through the press and media, and in practice public social media posts may be assessed in this context. However, the aim of the post must be to bring about an investigation or a sanction against you. Without that aim, the incident is more likely to be treated as insult.

How long does a false accusation case take?

The investigation stage usually lasts between a few months and a year; if a case is brought, the trial in the criminal court of first instance may last more than a year, and the appeal (istinaf) and, depending on the length of the sentence, the appeal to the Court of Cassation (temyiz) may be added to this. These durations vary from file to file and give only a general idea.

How much moral compensation can be obtained for false accusation?

The law sets no fixed amount. The judge decides at their discretion, taking into account the seriousness of the accusation, how widely it spread, consequences such as police custody or pre-trial detention, and the circumstances of the parties. For this reason, it would not be right to give a figure without reviewing your file; it is important to give reasons for the amount claimed.

About the Author

Av. Kaan Karanfiloğlu is the founder of Karanfiloglu Law Firm, a registered law firm based in Istanbul serving Turkish and international clients across Turkey. He is a lawyer registered with the Istanbul Bar Association (Registration No. 58270) and the Union of Turkish Bar Associations (No. 133074), and he has practised law in Turkey since 2017. He received his law degree (LL.B.) from Galatasaray University Faculty of Law in 2016 and advises clients in Turkish, English and French; clients who speak Russian and Chinese are served through native-speaking interpreters who work at the office. He is also a registered mediator (Registration No. 41909).

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about Turkish law and does not constitute legal advice. Laws, regulations, official fees and procedures change over time, and every situation is different. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your own circumstances. No liability is accepted for any loss arising from reliance on the information in this article.

The content on this site is for general information and does not constitute legal advice.

Related articles

ContactCallWhatsApp